The Perfect Curve

opinions, & assorted commentary

Welcome to The Perfect Curve.

176 dispatches in edition

Lead Story

Jackdaw and the UK energy mix

Audio Edition:

In a not-entirely-unpredicted move, the UK Government has announced that it is going to give the go-ahead for drilling to start in the Jackdaw gas field in the North Sea.

In not-entirely-unpredicted counter-news, the Tories have complained about it being too little, too late, and the environmentalists are saying the decision will contribute further to the climate catastrophe.

In reality, it will neither solve the UK's energy security problem or bring down bills for domestic consumers, nor will it lead to further coastal erosion of the east coast of England or flooding of Southport on the west coast. In the global scheme of things there's only a few cubic litres of gas down there, the way energy is priced on the international market is effectively a cartel anyway, and wherever the gas people use comes from, people are going to use the gas anyway.

It's this last point which I want to talk about in order to explain why the decision to allow drilling isn't the disaster the environmentalists say it is, and how it could have the potential to be beneficial, environmentally.

The Energy Mix

In terms of the main sources of where we get our energy from - gas, nuclear, wind, bio, and solar - the latter four are pretty much fixed in terms of what they can deliver; the nuclear reactors sit there and react, the wind blows, the compost rots, and the sun shines. We cannot spin up a new reactor when we need more electricity, we can't make the wind blow any harder (in fact when the wind is blowing too hard we have to turn the wind generation off), and we can't make the sun shine any brighter. In a very real sense, we take what we're given from these sources and be grateful.

It's not entirely unknown for there to be occasions when the sun and the wind are just right in late summer and early autumn that we can generate our electricity solely from our low carbon and renewable sources, and indeed generate more electricity than we actually need - when this happens, we export it through the France and Norway interconnectors. For the most part, though, these sources are not meeting all the need, and that energy needs to come from somewhere else.

Bridging the Energy Gap

There are two sources for bridging the energy gap when this happens - we import the shortfall in electricity from the various interconnectors which are part of the global energy grid, and we use gas, whether we're using that gas to heat our homes or using it to generate more electricity, whether we're using our own gas or whether we're using Norway's gas.

Gas is bad, but not as bad as it's made out

But here's the, shall we say, beauty of gas; unlike our low carbon and renewable forms of energy, gas can literally be turned off and on by the tap at the drop of a hat - we can store it, and we can increase or decrease extraction when stored stocks are running low or almost replenished. So with gas we can easily balance our shortfall of other energy generation in real time (and the people managing the gas and energy grids literally do balance it in real time, and it's paid for at the wholesale end similarly in real time), opening and closing the taps as demand rises and falls compared with the other sources of generation.

In an ideal world, we would have enough low carbon and renewable generation capacity not only to generate our electricity but to heat our homes, and we'd always be able to either sell any surplus electricity abroad through the interconnectors, or if everybody is experiencing surplus, brake the wind turbines and put covers over the solar panels.

But we are not in that ideal world; for the foreseeable future, we are going to need the convenience of gas for our overall heating and our electricity, and it surely makes sense to use our own gas rather than buying Norway's gas, even if due to how the North Sea licences were dished out in the 1980s that means our taxpayer is not benefiting from it now the way Norway's taxpayers are continuing to benefit.

In a world slightly more ideal than the one we live in, but still not completely ideal, the profits from increased gas production from the Jackdaw field could at least be invested in increased future production of renewables, rather than that investment having to come from the Education budget or the Defence budget.

What would you do?

If you're interested at playing the role of the Energy Secretary or Grid Manager, I've made a fun interactive tool - The Energytron - which lets you see what happens if you increase nuclear generation, or see how many more solar farms you'll need to reduce gas.

Dispatch

Botched executions in the USA

As yet another execution in the USA is botched, it's worth pointing out that the death penalty there is designed to be Cruel And Unusual by design; by design it causes the maximum amount of stress and trauma to the condemned person, even when it is not botched.

Even when everything goes smoothly to plan, the methods used to judicially murder people — gas chamber, lethal injection, electric chair, and firing squad — draw the process out as the condemned is marched from their cell to the execution chamber, and tied to a gurney, a chair, or a post, and any further preparations made before the execution itself is delivered.

And then when the process itself is started, it

[…]
0 Replies

Dispatch

Conviction and punishment for sexual assault

Over on Threads, another user said thus:

Castration for sex offenders should just be a basic requirement.

It's not an unpopular thing to say; the urge to viscerally respond to a viscerally wicked crime is understandable.

There are many reasons why it's not actually a good idea, not least because, as I replied:

Well, it might stop the ability to reoffend with the penis being the principle weapon used in the assault, but there are plenty of ways of sexually assaulting people without using one’s penis as a weapon, and indeed it wouldn’t stop the ability for a physically stronger person to exercise violent control over a physically weaker person, which is mainly what most people who commit sexual assault are doing.

To which the other person replied to the effect that the death

[…]
0 Replies

Dispatch

Leadership elections

Leadership elections for membership organisations — how’s this for a process:

All those who would be leader declare their candidacy and are nominated for the election by however many signatures from whatever constituency the organisation decides as an appropriate gatekeeping method.

The nominated candidates are then put forward to the membership to vote by ranked preferences, the voter marking as many preferences as they wish.

The counting of those ballot papers, however, is done twice — a count using the Alternative Vote method (which will tend towards the most preferred candidate) and a count using the Condorcet method (which will tend towards the least disliked candidate).

If both counts result in the same candidate at the top that’s grand, and that candidate is duly elected winner.

If the counts result in two different candidates at

[…]
0 Replies

Dispatch

Private sector forms functionality - just as bad if not worse than the public sector

In #LocalGov #LocalGovDigital we're rightly concerned about how too much of our online service design and user experience falls short of the high expectations many of us would like to see of it.

But having to deal with an online letting agent's landlord/tenant portal right now, oh my days, the worst pothole form I've ever completed is a breeze compared to this.

Speaking to somebody from the letting agent's office just, she said 'I have a word for it', which I responded 'the word I have for it is abomination!' She went on to say at the previous place she worked they tried the particular product portal for a week and got rid of it it was so bad.

It's the year 12,023 of the Human Era. The Internet should be better than

[…]
0 Replies

Dispatch

Never Mind The Glen Miller, Here's The Sex Pistols

I posted the following on Facebook two years ago. The people who were 16 when Never Mind The Bollocks came out are this year now 62.

#marketing #advertising #stereotypes

Today is a significant day not just in music history, but in marketing history.

It's 44 years to the day since the UK release of the Sex Pistols' debut album, Never Mind The Bollocks, Here's The Sex Pistols.

'What is the significance of a 44th year anniversary?', I hear you ask.

Well, let me answer that question for you.

44 years ago today, when the album was released, people who were 16 on that date would have been born in 1961. ie, people who were born in 1961, would have been old enough to

[…]
0 Replies

Public / Third Sector Digital

So you want to build a new council website, but why? What's wrong with your current one?

The public sector digital legend that is Dave Briggs has recently started a collaborative project, the New Council Website Playboard - a shared generic high level plan for councils to use as a starting point for their own website redevelopment projects.

One of the cards I've added to it is 'Carry out an Irritations Audit'.

What does this mean? Well, pour yourself a drink and get a biscuit and I'll tell you.

If you're wanting to rebuild, redesign, re-whatever your council website, then there's obviously something wrong with the existing one. In my experience, what people feel is wrong with it boils down to one of two things (or sometimes both) - either the technology that makes the website happen, the web Content Management System, or the content itself. This analysis

[…]

Dispatch

The Royal Family figureheads

Notwithstanding I’m actually interested in neither the Mountbatten-Windsor family nor the football, but I am interested in passing comment on the internets, but…

When Prince William, the El Presidente of the Football Association sends a good luck video message to the English ladies ahead of their forthcoming performance in a noteable challenge cup final saying he’s sorry he can’t be there in person, isn’t that a bit rude of him? I mean, yeah, he’s a busy man, he has important work to do, but is what he’s got scheduled for the weekend so important it can’t be put off, so he can be there to support the people he’s the figurehead for in person?

One of the tenuous arguments in favour of the retention of a monarchy is that the royal family

[…]
0 Replies

Public / Third Sector Digital

To Microsite or Not To Microsite, or, What’s the council website actually for?

I’ve not been involved in council website content for a good few years now, but obviously that hasn’t stopped me taking an interest in it. 

In my early years working in local government, my job was as Web Communications Officer, working initially as part of a directorate — a group of related service areas — communications team, then moving to the Corporate Webteam in the Corporate Communications team. As a directorate Web Communications Officer it was essentially my job to take facts from service areas within my team’s portfolio and turn those facts into engaging web copy. Sometimes I got to play journalist a little too, such as when I attended the statutory public inquiry associated with a major infrastructure project within my portfolio and summarised the proceedings as part of

[…]

Public / Third Sector Digital

Information Governance and the PSNI data breach

On the PSNI data breach, it’s important to remember there’s an individual somewhere who right now just wants to find the Marianas Trench and dive into it. Their management chain, mindful of their own legal and financial liability for the breach, will be looking to shift as much blame as possible down the tree to the individual.

They’ll point to the annual mandatory training all employees have in information governance, and say it’s therefore entirely the individual employee’s fault that this monumental stuff up took place.

No.

Mandatory annual information governance training does little to actually prevent accidental data breaches from occurring; the purpose of mandatory information governance training isn’t to prevent breaches, it’s so that when a breach happens the organisation can throw their employee to the wolves and say ‘well

[…]